Friday 13 June 2008

Canadian comedy's fatal flaw


REACH FOR THE TOP: There were high-fives all around at the CBC this week with the announcement that 20th Century Fox Television had bought the U.S. rights for an adaptation of Little Mosque On The Prairie. Apparently, there had been interest in the show south of the border for some time before Fox and Westwind Pictures announced the deal at Banff�s World Television Festival. The Canadian producer had also been negotiating with Fox before the Hollywood writers� strike forced them to take a temporary break.

According to a Hollywood Reporter story, the deal doesn�t preclude the original Canadian version from being aired stateside and Westwind�s Mary Darling, executive producer of the CBC version, said that they were pleased with the deal.

�Fox got the creative vision of the show, that it has to be funny while it treads sensitively on certain Muslim issues," Darling told the Hollywood Reporter.

I�m aware that Canadians � and especially Canadian media executives � are programmed to say things like this, but here�s where I really start to worry. Treading sensitively might sound like a prudent course for a politician, but it�s a sure recipe for bad comedy, and I�d like to hope that whoever ends up making Fox�s version of Little Mosque � no writer has been attached to the show yet � will not tread lightly around any issues; Muslim, Christian, Buddhist, Jewish, Jain, Hindu or Zoroastrian.

I am not a fan of the CBC show. Not because of its subject matter or setting, but because it�s simply dire comedy with limp, lifeless, "ba-dump-dump" comic set-up and delivery that feels dated by managing to channel the stalest essence of 3-camera laugh-track sitcoms in a single-camera, laugh-track-free setting � an unrewarding sleight-of-hand that Canadian comedy is too fond of replicating.

The best comedy is cruel and irreverent and Fox, for all its many flaws (Family Guy, I�m looking at you), is aware of this irrevocable comic law. Anyone hoping to make a comedy that �treads sensitively� would have to either be a fool � or a Canadian. This is, after all, a country that�s made itself an international laughing stock in the past few months with a series of Star Chamber trials convened by national and provincial Human Rights Commissions aiming to proscribe free speech and freedom of the press, all in the interest of making sure we all �tread sensitively.� Canadians like to flatter themselves that we�re a funny people; we�re funny, all right, but in all the wrong ways, I�m sorry to say.










See Also